Cryptolens and Carcha Seal side by side
| Topic | Cryptolens | Carcha Seal |
|---|---|---|
| Where it runs | A hosted service, with EU data residency on the Business plan. A License Server add-on, a separate subscription, runs on a computer in your customer's network and forwards requests to the hosted service or answers from its cache. Its pages describe no self-hosted installation of the platform itself. | Hosted at seal.carchalabs.com: sign up for a 14-day trial with no card, and each account gets its own server address and signing key. Or on your own server under a written agreement with Carcha Labs and a server license (a new installation runs a 14-day evaluation). After 12 consecutive months of a self-hosted subscription, the server license carries a perpetual fallback: the server keeps issuing on the version it runs, even if the subscription ends or Carcha Labs stops operating. |
| Price | Business €299/month (5,000 active licenses, 250,000 API requests a month), Scale €699 (10,000; 1,000,000), Enterprise custom. 30-day free trial without a credit card, then a limited free tier (10 active licenses). | Not published yet. The hosted trial is free for 14 days, no card needed. |
| License models | Node-locked, floating, subscription, trial, usage-based (pay per use) and user-based (customers sign in instead of entering a key). | Node-locked and floating licenses, perpetual or with an expiry, with end of updates, features and one trial per computer. No metered or named-user licenses. |
| Floating / concurrent licenses | Yes: each running process takes a seat by default, or each device when the app sends a stable machine code; the app renews it within a floating interval it sets. Optional overdraft. Offline through the License Server add-on. | Yes: seats in use at the same time, on any computer, counted per machine, running copy, user, or user per machine; hosted or self-hosted. The console shows the seats in use, frees a seat, and keeps the highest number in use each day. No license server at your customer's site (on-premise floating) in version 1. |
| Offline use | A signed response (RSA) works as a license file. The app decides how long it accepts one, measured from its signing date. | Ed25519-signed leases verified in the app; 72 hours between check-ins plus 7 days of grace on the default policy (both per policy). |
| Computers that never go online | Activation files from the dashboard, or an activation form where the customer submits the key and machine code. | Request file, license file and deactivation file; customers upload the request at /offline. |
| License server with no internet access | The License Server add-on in offline mode answers only from its cache. Floating seats it serves offline are counted locally and not synchronised with Cryptolens. | The self-hosted server renews its own server license by file exchange and makes no call home, so it runs on a network with no internet access. Customers activate and release seats by file. |
| SDKs | .NET, Unity/Mono, Java, Python, C/C++, Android and iOS, PHP, Go and Node, plus integrations for AutoCAD, Rhino/Grasshopper, Maya, AutoLISP, AutoHotKey and Excel add-ins. | Electron main process and Node.js 22.13+ (@carchalabs/seal-electron, proprietary, under the Carcha Seal Vendor Terms); a native module verifies leases a second time. C++ (header-only, built with CMake) and .NET (CarchaLabs.Seal on NuGet, .NET 5+ and .NET Framework 4.6.2+) SDKs with the same behaviour, over a native library in Rust. |
| Try without signing up | 30-day trial (account required). | Live demo in the browser, a sandbox key and npx @carchalabs/seal-quickstart, no sign-up. |
Which one fits
Choose Cryptolens if
- you sell on usage (pay per use) or want customers to sign in with an account instead of entering a key;
- your app runs in a host or language Carcha Seal does not cover: Java, Python, Go, PHP, mobile, or an AutoCAD, Rhino or Excel add-in;
- you need floating seats at a customer's site with no internet access today, through the License Server add-on;
- you want a hosted service with published plans by active license count.
Choose Carcha Seal if
- you want the whole license server on your own infrastructure: Carcha Seal ships a private server image under a written agreement, and it needs no connection to Carcha Labs;
- your customers’ computers never reach the internet: activation, deactivation and seat release by file are built into the server, with an upload page for customers;
- you want leases in standard formats you can verify yourself (JWS, Ed25519, JWKS), and clock-rollback detection in the SDK;
- your app is Electron or Node.js, C++ or .NET, and you want floating seats counted per machine, running copy or user without writing the renewal loop yourself.
An alternative to Cryptolens: how to move
Write with your current setup: your products and license terms, how your customers activate, whether any of them work without internet access, and the language your app is written in. Messages go straight to engineering, not to a sales queue, and the answer says whether it fits and what a move would take.
Step-by-step migration guide · How offline verification works · Software license types · Watch the live demo